| Platinum | Sazzy B - Kenosha Restaurant |
| Gold | Bristol 45 Diner |
| Silver | Sieberts Pub |
| Bronze | Mad Rooster Cafe |
| Top Pick | Frank's Diner |
| Top Pick | House of Gerhard Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Phoenix Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The 1844 Table & Mash |
| Top Pick | Tommy's Home Run Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Trolley Dogs |