| Platinum | American Made BBQ |
| Gold | Mission Bbq |
| Silver | Apple Holler |
| Bronze | Texas Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | BBQ'd Productions Sports bar & Grill Kenosha |
| Top Pick | Hillery's Bar BQ |
| Top Pick | Hillery's Kenosha Bar-B-Q |
| Top Pick | Route 20 Outhouse |
| Top Pick | Smokie Boyz BBQ |