| Platinum | Mueller's Tire |
| Gold | Kenosha Tire |
| Silver | Tires Plus of Kenosha |
| Bronze | Costco |
| Bronze | Mueller Auto Center |
| Top Pick | C & M New & Used Tires |
| Top Pick | Car Corral |
| Top Pick | Daves AM Discount Brake |
| Top Pick | DD Tire and service |
| Top Pick | Ed's New & Used Tires |