| Platinum | Infusinos Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Gold | Ruffolo's Special Pizza 2 |
| Silver | Italian American Club |
| Bronze | Luigi's Pizza Kitchen & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cut Stone Foods |
| Top Pick | Frankie D's Vino and Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Stella's Casa Capri |
| Top Pick | Tenutas |
| Top Pick | Tuscany Bistro Bar & Grill |